November 1, 2019 4:00pm by David Farrar

Open and Transparent Part XXIX

Newly-released emails reveal Finance Minister Grant Robertson’s staff tried to keep secret Treasury’s criticism of a government proposal, but were unsuccessful. …
Earlier this year, RNZ revealed Treasury had rubbished the so-called “feebate” scheme aimed at promoting electric cars, warning it would have virtually no effect on carbon emissions over two decades.
That advice was obtained by RNZ under the Official Information Act, but fresh correspondence reveals Mr Robertson’s office had tried to stop Treasury from releasing it.
The documents show Treasury initially intended to release its advice in full with just the names and contact details of certain staff redacted.
But officials in the minister’s office were quick to try reverse that decision, first suggesting it be withheld because the advice related to a draft Cabinet paper.
Treasury staff pushed back, saying the draft was “near-final”, so Ombudsman guidance indicated it must be made public.
“We therefore believe the release should remain as it is,” the email said.
The minister’s economic advisor, Alastair Cameron, then tried a different tack, asking Treasury to consider withholding its advice on the grounds of confidentiality.

Cameron is a former Chief of Staff for Labour and longtime activist.

Bravo to Treasury for standing up to the Minister’s office and obeying the law.